This column was recently published in Newsday. It was written by a high school freshman and explains why teachers need to write professionally. Do you think her point is valid? Are a few occasional mistakes okay, it's not a big deal, after all teachers are only human? Have standards been relaxed? Are students learning what they should in school? Are today's teachers good role models?
Newsday.com
EXPRESSWAY: A memo to my 'teacher's (sic)'
BY JANINE PERRI
Janine Perri lives in Holbrook.
May 31, 2008
As a freshman attending one of the larger school districts on Long Island, I always expected to receive an excellent education from a staff of knowledgeable teachers and administrators. Recent events, however, have prompted me to think otherwise.
In a stairwell near the library of my high school, I noticed a flier: "Future Teacher's Party! All member's must attend!" I was shocked at the misspellings - teacher's instead of teachers or teachers', and member's instead of members. The fact that the "member's" and "teacher's" involved with the flier were part of the Future Teachers of America Club was sheer irony.
I don't know if the flier was created by a teacher or by a "future teacher," but I was amazed that such mistakes could pass by unnoticed in an institution filled with instructors who are supposed to further my education.
When the flier was taken down and shown to the administrator who will be the principal of the school next year, he couldn't find the errors. His response when they were pointed out to him? A mere shrug and a claim that "everyone makes mistakes."
While this is certainly true, there's a difference between making an occasional mistake that can be overlooked and complete carelessness. Had such a mistake happened only once, it could be disregarded. But misspellings tend to be common in the district.
A flier hanging in the school hallways earlier this year advertised the upcoming comedy show auditions, asking, "Do you think your funny?" This mistake (your instead of you're), unlike the recent one, was noticed, as a piece of paper with a correction was taped over the misspelling a few days later.
Several years ago, an elementary school billboard "congradulated" the winners of a spelling bee, while "kindergarden" registrations were taking place in another elementary school in the district.
I'm sure my district isn't the only one with this problem. Misspellings and mistakes reflect poorly on a school district, showing the carelessness of educators and administrators. If misspellings are common, what does that say about the education that students are receiving?
Poor spelling and grammatical errors make people seem uneducated. What will the colleges the students apply to think? What about their future employers?
As for the "member's/teacher's" flier, I can't believe that, in a building filled with upwards of 300 educators, no one seems either to have noticed the mistake or brought it to the attention of the administration. If students are expected to uphold certain standards with grammar and spelling, shouldn't teachers do so as well? If teachers are unable to find simple mistakes that are unacceptable for an elementary student, how well are they really teaching us?
It makes you question today's teaching standards and wonder how much students actually learn in school, compared with how much know-ledge they gain on their own.
Copyright © 2008, Newsday Inc.